There are plenty of jargon obsessed reactionary grad students out there. Some of them visited this blog rather frequently last February. My frustration with the academic labor movement's discourse has more to do with the move which pops up every now and then to collapse though metaphor the struggles of casualized academics with those of migrant farmworkers or other migrant workers in unstable and often extralegal sectors of the service economy. My problem with this gesture is that rather than highlighting the instability of casualized academic work and the erosion/ negation of job security in the university, it places non-academic workers in the silent position of equivalent value, of placeholder, as silent bearers of abjected meaning, and elides the very real differences between academics and other workers in the University-Hospital city. This makes academics look like spoiled brats drunk on white privilege.
I bring this up in the spirit of respectful disagreement because -- without speaking for anyone else -- I personally have felt rather alienated by the tendency of academic labor activists to stretch for accusation opportunities. I believe it weakens the overall argument regarding casualized labor, and buttresses the view of graduate student unionists as polemical, hyper-jargon-obsessed reactionaries. Personally, I don't hold that view, since in my experience graduate student unionists are people who have invested a great deal of time and energy in thinking about their role in education and the future of the Academy, and are committed to acting to make the Academy better. But when something like this "boot camp" comes along that, for everything I can see, _does_ in fact make things better for graduate students, tearing it apart on principle calls that commitment into question. It makes people (including me, at times) wonder whether graduate student unionists are more committed to the ideology than to the change.
But, and this will come as a surprise to no one who reads this blog, more nuanced, democratic, and egalitarian solidarities are not only possible between the academic labor movement and other workers' struggles, but are one of the former's greatest hopes. Similarly, I think movements for educational and economic justice in this country need to engage in a deeper critique of the corporatization of and labor politics within and involving colleges and universities. As i noted here:
Finally, I want to argue that the neoliberal university 's ever increasing involvements in finance capital, real estate speculation, biopiracy, and the casualization of academic labor constitute something to be worried about and to organize against. The U.S. academy is in a very real crisis now precisely for this reason. In so arguing I am not claiming the primacy of graduate student unionization over other struggles, but instead calling for a perspective which understands the entanglements of the "global university" or "enterprise university" or whatever you want to call it in a more nuanced and delicate way than "universities are liberal oases that do good things full of ridiculous people who are way too radical," which i take to be the gist of Devlin's objection.
Alek understands this as well as I do, I suspect. But when he asks, regarding the dissertation boot camp, whether my objections belie a commitment to ideology over change, I wonder how easy the two are to extricate from each other, whether "boot camp" as a means of improving graduate students lives can ever really be understood outside the context of an abyssmal job market created by ever-increasing labor casualization, efforts around the country to crack down on time to degree themselves inseparable from concerns over the management and disposition of casual teaching labor. As I said in my initial response to Alek's comment, my issue is less with the boot camp as such than as metaphor for a certain relationship between university administrators and the people who teach upwards of two thirds of their courses. But
I will vociferously defend the importance of understanding the salience and implications of this metaphor as part of a broader critique of the ways in which how universities work and what they do has real effects on the rest of the labor movement, on workers lives, and on the global economy.
I'm not sure if I managed to say what I was trying to say here, but regardless, I'm hungry and there's no food in the apartment, so this is what you get.
I appreciate your taking time to respond, and the respect you showed in addressing seriously what, I realize, might have felt like a personal accusation and challenge to this blog.
ReplyDeleteI willingly grant that, of course, a commitment to ideology can be (usually is) deeply connected with a commitment to change. I used the somewhat cheap rhetorical device of posing them as opposites in order to underscore the difference between the very "academic" pursuit of developing/proclaiming an ideology and the less "academic" pursuit of pragmatically strategizing to move an organizing program forward. They're not exclusive, but I worry that a) graduate student unionization efforts may privilege the former, and b) that, in doing so, they damage their chances of achieving the latter.
If the arguments for grad unionization exhibit (or appear to exhibit) a greater commitment to dissecting the machinery of the new global university, and if they do so using a rhetoric steeped in jargon and critical theory, I believe it's easy to misinterpret the priorities of grad student union proponents. I wish I could say that you'll just be judged on what you've accomplished, but it seems clear that, instead, people will judge what you've done based on who/what they believe you to be.
The effect that has on the general public and NYU might not matter (though it probably does), but it certainly figures hugely in the organizing process.
That's why an understanding of who grad student unionists are, and what they want, will be so critical to the success of grad student unionization. Ultimately, people want to know what a grad union's for, and what its supporters care about.
There may be multiple functions, and multiple issues, but if the chosen tool is collective bargaining, then the primary purpose needs to be improving the working life of the people in the unit. And the issues need to speak directly to that.
I've often felt tempted to ask: "So, do you want a union so that you can alter the Academy's semiotic relationship with the world? Or do you want a union so you can be a good teacher and survive?"
Again, not mutually exclusive. I just think that people who are motivated by a variety of purposes need to consider the position they're in -- unprotected by law, without a contract at any private university in the US, viewed, often accurately, as among the most privileged people in our society, etc. -- and think about how they want to frame who they are and what they care about.
Everyone working person deserves a union, but, unfortunately, the only people that get them are people that went about winning them strategically.
That's all aside from my personally frustrated response, which I detailed in the earlier comment. You shouldn't feel at all compelled to respond to that, since its a matter of individual difference.