Sunday, November 11, 2007

addendum

this is pretty great, and reminds me of some of the lighter (read, colder) moments from the NYU strike.

3:30 p.m. One writer suggests that we walk counter-clockwise. A minor fracas occurs between those who think this is a great idea and those who believe it might undo all our work for the past two and a half hours.

Saturday, November 10, 2007

Why You SHOULD Support The Writers' Strike

Yes, there's something alluring, if anachronistic (hearkening back to Hollywood's red days and the pre-HUAC thirties) and perhaps ridiculous about the photographs of America Ferrera and, in Grey's Anatomy scrubs, Sandra Oh and Ellen Pompeo walking the WGA picket lines in solidarity with the strikers, and press has tended to focus on the disruptions the strike causes (no more Daily Show, so much for Steven Colbert's presidential aspirations, etc, how will we ever get to see Jack Bauer valorize torture?) rather than what's at stake in the demands and dispute which have brought us to this moment.

I want to argue that you should support the strike, not ironically, and not only because it's the right thing to do to support strikes that aren't hate strikes and aren't out to disenfranchise one group of workers at another's expense, but instead because what's at stake here winds up being rather important.

Sure, the Jane Espensons of the world aren't exactly an immiserated proletariat. They make lots of money. They don't work in mines. They're mostly white, mostly male. Why should you give a fuck?

Because what's at stake here winds up being the relationship between the labor that generates "intellectual property" and the ownership and distribution rights of said "property, a key question" for those of interested in questions of what Andrew Ross has called "the Mental Labor problem," or what the Italian autonomist marxists - notably Lazzarato, call immaterial labor - the labor that generates the informational and cultural content of the commodity. What control intellectual workers should have over what they produce winds up being relevant to a far broader swathe of workers than well-paid TV writers. Think of international graduate student researchers in biology labs at universities all over the country, helping to produce pharmaceutical and other medical patents in which they will have no ownership rights. The two cases are not quite the same - the writers are simply asking for a stake in one particular arena, that of digital reproduction of the tv show - but still they seem to be to be calling the question of who owns and profits from intellectual work.

We may, ultimately, want to throw out the entire concept of intellectual property as extremely deleterious for much of the world, or as now stifling the very innovation it was supposed to encourage and protect. That's fine. I don't think such a goal and supporting the strikers demands are mutually exclusive though. As long as profit is the extraction of the unpaid (excess) labor that goes into the production of a commodity, attempts to recognize that labor, to bring it to the fore, are important and worth fighting for.

That said, we can't ignore the role that other forms of labor play in the creation of the tv show as a commodity and as a unit of intellectual property. We can't fetishize the writers and their celebrated creative work as the only labor that makes possible the creation, or even the writing of a television show. I'm thinking not only of camerapeople, editors, set designers, but also parking productions assistants, janitors, food service workers, the workers who actually work in the factories that produce the dvds and tivos and home theater systems that have precipitated the so-called revolution in viewing which has led the writers to make the demands that the studios are refusing to meet, as well as, perhaps, the people who clean the writers' apartments, take care of their children, cook the food they eat. So while we should support the writer's strike, we should also insist that it be augmented, broadened to address the often invisible forms of labor that we don't often think about in conversations about creative labor and intellectual property.

Now back to my exam.

Friday, November 9, 2007

ipod shuffle

Donny Hathaway - "You've Got A Friend"

The Just Brothers - "Sliced Tomatoes." (Pretty cool, understated surf-soul guitar-driven instrumental.)

Little Milton - "More & More"

The Cure - "Torture." Rana's favorite song, clearly.

Marnie Stern - "Logical Volume"

Bob Marley and the Wailers - "Memphis" - from the early reggae period featuring the Upsetters and lots of soul covers aqnd some fantastic acoustic instrumentation.

The dB's "Ask For Jill." "There is a girl on the fourth or fifth floor/buzz at reception slightly disheveled." Not my favorite song off "Repercussions, but pretty good in that dB's shhepish masculinity kind of way.

Ghostface Killah - "Child's Play" The "Bridge is Over" interpellations make this song that much weirder.

The Clientele - "Monday's Rain"

Beatles - "Everybody's got something to hide except for me and my monkey." Possibly the best song title in the history of popular music

Sunday, November 4, 2007

We could make him change a flat tire, or we could all at once retire

I left the apartment at the crack of dawn and walked into bobst, graded two papers, one good and one extremely poor, which was disconcerting. I'm in the process of finishing "Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses," which is interesting and more engaging than i thought it would be based on previous engagement with Althusser. I've been using my dad's ancient copy of Lenin and Philosophy and it split in two last night, though the relevant essay remains intact, which i suppose is convenient.

I interrupted the Althusser twice Well, more than that, but there were two big interruptions. The first time was for lunch. On the way to corporate sweatshop burrito chain i ran into some former Yale grad students I knew from New Haven on the street and they were extraordinarily nice to me. I then stopped again to read this on one of the computers in LL1. It's still resonating in my brain. The whole weekend makes graduate school seem more exciting and useful and good than it has been thus far, and that's no small feat given how low i've sunk at various points throughout the last year or two.

Anyway, random shuffle:
Pavement - "Here"
Ultramagnetic MC's "Mentally Mad"
Nick Drake - "Road"
Clipse - "We Got It For Cheap"
Charles Mingus - "Wham Bam Thank You Ma'am"
Super Rail Band - "Maliyo"
Clash - "Tommy Gun"
Spoon - "Sister Jack"
Desmond Dekker - "Music Like Dirt"
The Coup - " 5 Million Ways to Kill a CEO"

Saturday, November 3, 2007

“The camera relieves us of the burden of memory. It surveys us like God, and it surveys for us. Yet no other god has been so cynical, for the camera records in order to forget.”

That's John Berger, from Ways of Seeing, i think. Anne McClintock quoted it today in her talk at the conference at Barnard to commemorate the 20th anniversary of Hazel Carby's Reconstructing Womanhood, in reference to Abu Ghraib, Gitmo, and the visual politics of torture. McClintock's piece was insightful and provocative, but Berger's claim is itself deeply provocative, and i think it is often true, Cure songs not withstanding, ( or perhaps Smith's lyrical persona constructed through the tropes of loss and a very obvious disintegration is instead illustrative.) So I am glad that i took no pictures today, to apply said insight in the most banal, generalized, and dehistoricized of all possible ways, because it was not something I want or intend to forget.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

racist ex-defense secretaries and their Yalien apologists

In a series of internal musings and memos to his staff, then-Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld argued that Muslims avoid "physical labor" and wrote of the need to "keep elevating the threat," "link Iraq to Iran" and develop "bumper sticker statements" to rally public support for an increasingly unpopular war...

"You are running a story based off of selective quotations and gross mischaracterizations from a handful of memos -- carefully picked from the some 20,000 written while Rumsfeld served as Secretary," Rumsfeld aide Keith Urbahn wrote in an e-mail. "After almost all meetings, he dictated his recollections of what was said for his own records."


I'd post a link to that blogpost KU put up a couple years ago applauding a french motorist for running down and nearly murdering a muslim man on the grounds that he looked like Osama Bin Laden, but he wisely seems to have removed said blog from the internet...